A Thumb on the Scale(s)?

Years back I remember being part of a Q&A with a group of plan sponsors—the focus was the challenge of not only getting, but keeping their plans in compliance, while also looking for creative ways to engage and encourage participants. Then at one point, a tired looking gentleman, expressing frustration with the pressures of audits and litigation, said: “I wish the DOL would just tell us what to do.” 

I cautioned him at the time that he ought to be careful what he wished for—that he might just get it.

Sure enough, in mid-March the Labor Department issued a “compliance assistance release” which was unique both in format and, arguably, focus. It reminded plan fiduciaries of the significance of their review and assessment of prudence of plan investments—and then said in no uncertain terms that it had concerns about the ability of cryptocurrency to meet those high standards. Indeed, the release plainly stated that those who did include such options could “expect to be questioned about how they can square their actions with their duties of prudence and loyalty…”—not just as standalone options on the menu, but even through a brokerage account. And so, while not an outright prohibition, it seems fair to say that it’s likely to have what lawyers call a “chilling effect” on cryptocurrency as a 401(k) investment option.

In late December the Labor Department issued a statement on the use of private equity in participant-directed plans—stating that, except in a minority of situations, plan-level fiduciaries of small, individual account plans are not likely suited to evaluate the use of PE investments in designated investment alternatives (DIAs) in individual account plans. It represented a step back from a June 2020 information letter that affirmed that PE investments “as a component of a professionally managed multi-asset class vehicle structured as a target date, target risk or balanced fund” can be offered as an investment option for participants in defined contribution plans under ERISA. It seems likely that some private equity firms (or those promoting such investments) had taken the initial guidance as something of a green light to promote those options beyond the limitations of the original letter—leading the Labor Department to clarify its position—and, arguably, to shut down active consideration of those options, at least by “small, individual account plans.” 

And then, of course, there’s the focus on ESG options, which the Trump administration clearly tried to undermine with its proposed and then (slightly muted) final regulation—and which the Biden administration first announced that it would not enforce, and has since then, with its own proposed regulation, sought to swing the pendulum in favor of those options—arguably to the point of not only encouraging, but requiring, consideration of those factors.

The reality is, of course, that times change. And even if the long-standing precepts of prudence and fiduciary responsibility haven’t changed, the environment in which those determinations are made has. Cryptocurrency wasn’t a “thing” until fairly recently (and it didn’t take long to find its way into 401(k) platforms), and those who may have misapplied (accidentally or “on purpose”) the Labor Department’s statement on private equity needed to be reminded. ESG is certainly a relatively recent—though not brand new—focus—but plan fiduciaries can perhaps be forgiven for feeling a bit “whipsawed” by the shifting sentiments between administrations.

Generally well-intentioned, the perspective of even the most seasoned and expert regulatory professional sometimes fails to appreciate the impact in the “real” world. That’s the value in the access—and influence—that NAPA, armed with the input, insight and perspective of NAPA members, provides to these processes. Insight and influence that allows you to “put a thumb on the scale” in providing a practical and pragmatic perspective on the rules and regulations that guide our industry— now, and in the days ahead. 

- Nevin E. Adams, JD

p.s.: Speaking of which, this would be a great time to get involved via the NAPA DC Fly-In Forum. Check it out—and apply today—at https://napadcflyin.org.