Showing posts with label retirement confidence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label retirement confidence. Show all posts

Saturday, August 29, 2026

Kids, Confidence — and Causation

 It seems that having kids can be good for your retirement confidence.

At least that’s the headline regarding a new survey from Allianz Life that finds that Americans without children are significantly less confident in their ability to meet their retirement savings goal — 54%, compared with 72% of those with children.

Now I’m sure that result is supposed to be counter-intuitive because — let’s face it — kids are expensive. There’s food, clothing, childcare, education, healthcare and, in some cases, financial support long after they have theoretically “left” the nest. So, it would seem logical that Americans without children would have more money available for retirement — and greater confidence about their prospects.[i]

ad space
Parental Planning?

Well, as it turns out, it may not be children that account for the confidence — at least not directly. Rather, Allianz suggests that parenthood may provide a catalyst for financial planning. According to the survey, 62% of Americans without children don’t have a written financial plan, compared with 42% of parents.

There’s surely something to that. Having children has a way of bringing financial responsibilities into sharper focus. Suddenly, there are dependents to protect, college expenses to anticipate and estate-planning decisions to make. Even people who have been content to take their own financial future for granted may become more purposeful when someone else is counting on them.

But having a reason to plan isn’t the same as having the resources to succeed. Nor does confidence necessarily equate to readiness.

ad space
Confidence ‘Game’

Now, as a parent — and someone who believes that having a plan can not only inspire confidence, but help justify it — I’m reluctant to cast doubt on that conclusion.

That said, “Americans without children” is a broad category. It could include a 27-year-old who hasn’t had children yet, a 45-year-old who chose not to, someone (of indeterminate age) who wanted children but couldn’t have them, and an older adult who just never became a parent. Those individuals may have little in common beyond the survey category into which they have just been slotted.

Age alone could explain part of the confidence gap — as could marital status, household income, homeownership, employment, access to a workplace retirement plan, or whether the household has one income or two. At least from the published results, we don’t know whether the 18-point confidence difference persists after controlling for those factors.[ii]

ad space

There’s also the possibility that the assumed direction of cause and effect is backward. Perhaps having children causes people to plan and feel more confident. But it’s also possible that individuals who already feel financially secure are more willing to have children, while some who feel less secure decide they can’t afford to do so.

Then there’s the written financial plan. Having one may well increase confidence, but it could also simply be another manifestation of wealth, income or access to professional advice. More affluent households are likely both to have written plans and to feel more confident about retirement. The plan may contribute to that confidence without being its sole cause — or even the primary one. It may not even be a good or workable plan.

Let’s face it. The Allianz findings don’t establish that having children makes people better prepared for retirement. In fact, they don’t establish that having children is what produced the difference in confidence — only that parents in this survey were more confident.

ad space

Children may offer an incentive to plan — and perhaps an expectation of support later in life. But they also bring expenses that compete directly with retirement savings. Those without children may have fewer current obligations, but greater awareness that they will have to finance and manage more of their own care.

Look, far be it from me to discourage a healthy connection between having kids and retirement preparation. Having children can — and certainly should — provide plenty of motivation to plan for the future.

But, in and of themselves — and as much as they add to our lives — they’re no retirement plan.

ad space
  • Nevin E. Adams, JD

 


[i] Although among parents, those with one or two children were more confident than those with three or more, 74% versus 66%, respectively.

[ii] Indeed, survey participants generally needed annual household income of at least $50,000 for singles or $75,000 for married or partnered respondents — or at least $150,000 in investable assets. Consequently, the findings tell us less about lower-income households, where both the costs of raising children and the challenges of retirement saving may be even more pronounced.

Saturday, May 02, 2026

Retirement Realities Better Than Pre-Retirement Perspectives

 If you read only the headlines from the latest Employee Benefit Research Institute Retirement Confidence Survey, the takeaway feels familiar: confidence is slipping, worries are rising, and concern about retirement readiness is once again in focus.

Seriously?

Look, once you move past the year-over-year decline[i] and look at the levels themselves, the picture changes shape. Yes, confidence is down from recent highs. But retirees, in particular, remain broadly confident in their ability to live comfortably in retirement despite all the “noise” about inflation, Social Security, and volatile markets. Roughly three-quarters still say they feel secure about their financial footing in retirement. That is not a fragile number. It is a resilient one.

ad space

What stands out even more is how consistently the survey shows a gap between expectations and actual experience. Workers — still on the near side of retirement — are meaningfully less confident than those already in it. That pattern shows up again in the latest Retirement Confidence Survey, and it is one of the most important, if underappreciated, dynamics in the data. And why not? The drumbeat of bad economic news, unrealistic financial expectations, dramatically inflated lump-sum healthcare costs, and yes — lack of confidence — are incessant, even in this “longest-running survey of its kind.”

Considering the headline prisms journalists — and industry surveyors — routinely put in front of people, what else could you expect?

But — and as a current retiree — let me just affirm what the RCS is (still) telling us: retirement looks more uncertain when you are looking at it than when you are living it.

ad space

That asymmetry is not surprising, but it is revealing. Before retirement, the risks are abstract and cumulative — markets, inflation, healthcare costs, longevity. They tend to stack in the imagination. After retirement, those same risks become real, but also more bounded. Income sources are visible. Tradeoffs are immediate. Decisions replace speculation.

The result is often not a dramatic sense of abundance, but something more important: manageability.

That does not mean retirees are carefree, or that pressures like inflation are irrelevant. The modest decline in confidence this year almost certainly reflects real household strain — and what I (still) consider to be a valid concern that lawmakers will fumble the Social Security (and Medicare) foundation. But it is still a decline within a relatively high band —movement from strong confidence to slightly less strong confidence, not from confidence to doubt. A slight dip, not a crash.

Let’s face it — the most overlooked (and certainly unreported) signal in the data: those actually in retirement are still, by and large, saying it works.

ad space

Not perfectly. Not uniformly. But sufficiently — and more consistently than the pre-retiree mindset — or the headlines that fuel it — would suggest.

That gap between perception and experience is not closing. If anything, it remains one of the most durable features of retirement confidence research. And it carries an important implication: the further people are from retirement, the more uncertain it tends to feel. The closer they get — or the more they experience it — the more workable it often becomes.

Unfortunately, that is not a headline story — and it’s never going to get “clicks.” But it may be the real one worth paying attention to. 

ad space

And maybe, just maybe, it’s one YOU should share.

  • Nevin E. Adams, JD

 


[i] Typical headlines included Retirement Confidence Among Workers, Retirees Slips to Lowest Point in Nearly a Decade, Retirement Confidence Falls as Social Security Concerns Mount, Workers' Retirement Confidence Hits 9-Year Low: EBRI, Americans Are Losing Confidence in Having Enough for Retirement, Survey Says - WSJ, Workers’ and retirees’ confidence for a comfortable retirement continues to decline amid fears of changing government programs - Pensions & Investments,

Saturday, June 21, 2025

Perception Gaps

  A recent survey “revealed” a big disconnect between participants and plan sponsors — or did it?

The survey, conducted from mid-January to mid-February earlier this year by Voya, found that while 91% of sponsors thought participants were either very or somewhat prepared for retirement, “just” 69% of participants felt that way. A finding that I think it’s fair to say surprised — well, probably no one. 

Indeed, I’m sure there are any number of advisors out there who saw this as an opportunity to tell plan sponsors that while they may THINK the participants they serve and support are in good shape, their reality may be different. Particularly since this survey also found that advisors’ perspective was pretty much aligned with that of the participants surveyed.  

But could plan sponsors’ “read” of participant readiness really be so strong as to be so out of touch with participants’ perception? The authors of the report opined that the bull market might explain the level of plan sponsor positivity (which apparently is a consistent finding), though elsewhere in the report it cites that market volatility has been a factor of concern for participants — and so, one might suppose that, depending on when you responded to the survey, you might be inclined to feel better — or not — depending on the state of the market at the time (in fairness, the authors note that participant confidence has INCREASED since 2023, up from 63%). 

But as I thought about the data — or rather the conclusions drawn there — I noted that these are separate surveys of participants and plan sponsors — not just in time, but in…location. These are NOT the participants in the plans overseen by these specific plan sponsors, and these participant sentiments expressed are from participants not under the guidance/purview of the surveyed plan sponsors.[i] Perhaps if the plan sponsors associated with these particular participants’ plans were surveyed, they’d have a more muted confidence. Similarly, if the survey focused on participants in the plans overseen by this particular group of plan sponsors — well, they might actually be in a better situation, and thus more confident.

But even then, there’s a high likelihood that the vast majority of the participants surveyed have NEVER made even a single attempt to figure out their retirement needs/target,[ii] and so when asked about their level of confidence … well, it’s pretty likely to be an “uninformed” assessment. You can, of course, be confident — or lack confidence — for no good reason.  And who’s to say that the evaluation of the plan sponsors — who may have no specific sense of the retirement needs of their participant base — is any more credible?

Let’s face it — a macro view of the plan’s participant readiness (not to mention that some plan sponsors are more cognizant of such things than others) is almost certainly going to vary from the micro perspective of an individual. It’s not quite apples and oranges, but it’s at least comparable to assessing the quality of a bushel of apples compared to a couple at the bottom of the basket.

Beyond that, when you look inside the numbers of the Voya survey you see that just 17% of participants considered themselves VERY prepared — and only 27% of plan sponsors characterized their participant readiness as “very” prepared. So, while there’s a perception “gap,” it’s not as wide as the headlines proclaimed. 

All this by way of saying that while there is value[iii] in comparing (and contrasting) the perspectives of plan sponsors and participants from different places, at different times with different levels of understanding and evaluation…

Well, it’s a good idea to keep those differences in mind — particularly when trying to close those gaps in perception.

  • Nevin E. Adams, JD     

 


[i] I suppose some accidental overlap IS possible, but it seems unlikely.

[ii] If that question was asked, it wasn’t obvious from the results. Again, while confidence readings are easy to take, if you have no idea what you need (and perhaps a dated idea of what you have), I would argue it’s of little use in terms of gauging reality.

[iii] And, dare I say, click-throughs…

Saturday, October 19, 2024

10 Pet Peeves About the Retirement Industry

 Life is full of annoyances – all the better to appreciate the blessings that surround us. That said, there are things about the retirement industry that really bug me. 

I recently had the privilege of being part of the Leafhouse National Retirement Symposium. The theme was unfiltered – the unvarnished truth.  And it seemed an appropriate forum to share some of the things about the retirement industry that really bug me. 

Here’s the list:

Using the average or median retirement balance as a proxy for retirement readiness.

Generally speaking, retirement plans are comprised of a myriad of individual circumstances – participants of ages that run from late teens to beyond traditional retirement, savings behaviors based on income – and age – and company match… Not to mention that this might be only a half dozen years of a worker’s accumulation, with the rest on some other recordkeeping platform…

Why any rational person would think that combining those disparate elements and then either dividing them by the number of parts, or looking for some kind of middle grouping – well, it defies logic. And yet, this happens with distressing regularity. It’s worse than mush – it’s a mess – a nonsensical number that is easy to calculate, and completely meaningless. 

Asking people who have never tried to do a retirement needs calculation how much they’ll need for retirement – and then publishing that as an actual target.   

There is perhaps of some modest value in knowing how much people think they need for retirement – even if they have never actually sat down and tried to figure it out. Indeed, in recent weeks at least two major providers have done just that with headlines proclaiming that “magic” number. Setting aside for a moment the reality that it’s completely uninformed – the reality is that we know NOTHING about the incomes, lifestyle, health or residence of the individuals behind that “guess” (though USA Today actually took the time to ascertain the political affiliation of the respondents). 

And since we know nothing about their circumstances – and less about how they derived that number (much less how the uninformed choices of the survey population was construed into that final number) – well, why would anybody care? But while this COULD be a teachable moment – where the survey writers point out that the number might be wildly overblown, and the importance of doing an actual assessment…and then there’s…

Using survey results of people who have never done a retirement needs calculation to “prove” there’s a retirement crisis.

The aforementioned “reports” instead choose to present those “pulled out of their…” guesses as a valid conclusion, and one that not only confirms that (a) there is a retirement crisis (and just in case that point was missed, asking them AFTER they provide a retirement number), but that (b) there’s a crisis precisely because folks are never going to be able to achieve that made up number based on the average savings amount (see above).   

Saying there’s a retirement “crisis” without ever defining what that means.

“Crisis” is a word much bandied about these days, most particularly as a label applied to retirement — by foes and fans alike. Indeed, while not so long ago headlines posed that premise as a question (“Is there a retirement crisis?”), it is now generally posited as a current reality (often accompanied by an exclamation point) — even though an examination of objective data and a clinical application of the term “crisis” suggests otherwise.

For most in the retirement industry, it’s meant as a call to action – built on the notion that time is a valuable asset in helping retirement savings grow. But the dictionary definition is of an event or situation where disaster is imminent – something that calls for immediate, and potentially drastic action. And that is how the critics of the 401(k) see it, as they call for immediate drastic action to replace the 401(k) with some alternative (or to defund the 401(k) in order to build an alternative).  Those who claim there is a retirement crisis without context are, quite simply, fueling their fire.

Pretending that everybody used to have a defined benefit plan/pension – and that those who did received a full pension.

This is a hugely exaggerated myth – actually one built on another – and one invoked with growing frequency by those who claim that the 401(k) is an inferior model. One that was “never intended” to be a full retirement plan unlike its defined benefit pension cousin. What gets overlooked is just how few Americans in the private sector were actually covered by a defined benefit pension (29% at the peak), and even among those who were covered, how few actually worked for that employer long enough to qualify for a “full” pension (something on the order of 12% of those who were covered). 

Quite simply, only a very small minority of individuals (in the private sector) who were covered by a pension actually collected a full pension. If that was a plan design INTENDED to be a retirement plan, it didn’t do a very good job of it for most.

Next time: the rest of the list.

- Nevin E. Adams, JD

Saturday, July 27, 2024

The Plot to Kill the 401(k)…Thickens

 Critics of the 401(k) have moved way beyond mere bad-mouthing—and are now openly advocating actions that would undermine support for, and participation in, those programs.

It started with criticism of the 401(k) itself—how it was “never intended” to be a primary source of retirement income—as though that precluded the possibility. There were the insinuations that later became outright claims that—despite evidence to the contrary—401(k) plan benefits were “upside down” and that tax benefits accrued only to the rich. Then reports—based on small samplings of data—that employer matching contributions didn’t really impact/influence contribution levels—and that the match was…“unfair”—or “exploiting naïve myopic workers.”

More recently, there was the pining for the defined benefit plan design, even though it never really provided the level of benefits promised for most—and even though the vast majority of workers in the private sector never even had that as an option—and even though no serious analysis with a full appreciation of the costs (and risks) of businesses taking on those obligations sees that as a reality. 

Yes, for years now the 401(k) has suffered the Shakesperean “slings and arrows of outrageous fortune.” Sometimes the motivations of those throwing stones have been obvious—sometimes not.  Some are surely just academics desperate/eager to be published, others have a strong preference for/commitment to a federal government “solution,” rather than the private sector. Some—surely some—are honestly just motivated to examine and improve on that voluntary system—but limited by access to comprehensive data. 

Of course, one might instead more cynically wonder if there’s a deliberate reliance on distorting measures like averages and means extrapolated from accounts ranging from those at the beginning of their savings career with those nearing retirement—in that, the retirement industry itself has been complicit in its search for clicks and headlines, regardless of the messages those distortions perpetuate. Throughout, there have been criticisms about the lack of coverage and/or participation—but little acknowledgement that the system has long been considered as supplemental to that “big government” solution—Social Security (which, let’s face it, has challenges of its own).

Having laid that groundwork, in recent weeks, those voices have become increasingly bold in their condemnations. There’s no longer any pretense about their plans for the 401(k). Quite frankly, they plan to starve it to death—to redirect those tax deferrals to other projects, and not as deferrals, but as outright taxpayer-funded “grants.” Not so long ago, the notion of taking away the preferences that do, in fact, encourage participation—but more importantly foster sponsorship of these programs—would have been anathema to political prospects. Apparently, those days are now behind us.    

Little wonder that in the latest Retirement Confidence Survey by the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) and Greenwald Associates, the second-highest concern of survey respondents was that the U.S. government would make “significant changes to the America retirement system.” 

So, what can we do about all this? Here are some suggestions:

Call out those in Congress who want to strip away support for the 401(k). Here I am talking specifically about the sponsors of the latest attempt to undermine the private retirement system—the sponsors of the innocuously labeled “Retirement Savings for Americans Act” (RSAA). More specifically, I’m talking about Sens. John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.) and Thom Tillis (R-N.C.), as well as Reps. Terri Sewell (D-Ala. 7th) and Lloyd Smucker (R-Penn. 11th). Up until now, the sponsors have demurred on how this bill would be paid for—until Sen. Hickenlooper recently acknowledged that he would be willing to reduce the 401(k) incentives and limits to pay for the proposed plan, which would include a 5% federal match. That’s right—a 5% federal match. Those heading to the NAPA DC Fly-In Forum, take note!

Quit sharing and promoting “research” based on distorted or questionable data—and the organizations that produce them. Yes, I know you’re just trying to highlight the need for action, and perhaps to provoke a business opportunity. And yes, I know you don’t always have time to wade through the assumptions and math, not to mention biases in sampling size—or those that are simply surveys of individuals that don’t know any “better.” But if you feel compelled to share it, at least take the time to acknowledge that you haven’t had the chance to validate the results.  And come to https://www.napa-net.com where we try to keep you up to date on such things.

Support the organizations that are supporting and advocating for positive change and enhancements in these programs. If you’re reading this, you’re likely already a supporter of one of those (the National Association of Plan Advisors)—and good for you. You can (and should) also support those efforts by participating in committees, conferences, and education programs. And by sharing the information you find here. You can even start with this one!

Quit apologizing for the 401(k). That’s right. Even the 401(k)’s most vocal champions seem to be inclined to acknowledge “we still have work to do.” I’m not suggesting we ignore realities—but this “voluntary” retirement savings program has in a remarkably short period of time become THE way Americans save, and they have VOLUNTARILY set aside TRILLIONS of dollars for the future. To my eyes, this is a jaw-dropping incredible, amazing success. 

The failure laid at the feet of 401(k)s—if a failure it is—is that people who don’t work, or who don’t work for employers who offer a retirement plan at work, are in worse shape than those who do. Now, I’m not saying that the 401(k) design works for everyone, and it most assuredly won’t work for those who don’t have access to its benefits. That said, 401(k)s are working for far more people and in far more varied circumstances than the fear-mongering headlines give them credit for. It’s one thing, after all, to acquiesce to what has become a journalistic “creed”—that “if it bleeds, it leads”—and something else again to wield the knife. 

Those of us who see the impact it has made, and continues to make, on a daily basis need to be willing to say that. Out loud and proudly.

- Nevin E. Adams, JD